by David Green
•
13 March 2024
Post-COVID many organisations introduced a hybrid mixture of home and office working. But what are the pros and cons? The pros of hybrid working: Increased flexibility: Hybrid working allows staff to have a better work-life balance by giving them the flexibility to work from home on certain days. This can be particularly beneficial for those with long commutes or personal commitments. Improved productivity: Studies have shown that home working can increase productivity due to fewer distractions and interruptions in a home environment. Hybrid working allows staff to choose the most suitable environment for their tasks, leading to increased focus and efficiency. Cost savings: Hybrid working can result in cost savings. Staff can save money on commuting expenses, and meals etc. Employers can also save on office space and related expenses. Reduced environmental impact: With fewer people commuting to the office every day, hybrid working can contribute to a reduction in carbon emissions and traffic congestion, leading to a positive environmental impact. Enhanced satisfaction and retention: Offering hybrid working options can improve staff satisfaction and morale. It shows that the organisation values work-life balance and trusts staff to manage their time effectively. This, in turn, can lead to higher employee retention rates. The cons of hybrid working: Communication challenges: Hybrid working can create communication gaps between those in the office and those working at home. It may be more difficult to collaborate, share information, and maintain team cohesion, especially if not all staff have access to the same communication tools. Potential for decreased collaboration and innovation: In-person interactions often foster collaboration, creativity, and innovation. Hybrid working may limit spontaneous brainstorming sessions, informal conversations, and face-to-face problem-solving, which can hinder the development of new ideas. Blurred work-life boundaries: While hybrid working offers flexibility, it can also blur the boundaries between work and personal life. Some individuals may find it challenging to switch off from work when they are constantly connected to their home office. Inequality and fairness concerns: Hybrid working may not be feasible or accessible for all staff. Those with limited access to technology, suitable home working environments, or caregiving responsibilities may face disadvantages, leading to potential inequality and fairness concerns. Potential for decreased employee engagement: Without regular face-to-face interactions, some may feel isolated or disconnected from their colleagues and the organisational culture. This can impact engagement, motivation, and overall job satisfaction. Reinforcing existing prejudices and discrimination: Research by the TUC found that perceived issues with work commitment led to closer monitoring of hybrid workers from black and minority ethnic communities. The same study also found that hybrid working led to some people working longer and constantly being available in order to cope with increasing workloads or to prove their worth. It is important for organisations to consider all these pros and cons when implementing hybrid working and to find ways to address the potential challenges to ensure a successful transition. A good hybrid working policy can set out how such challenges can be avoided or overcome. For charities, a big problem is a lack of investment in IT. Traditionally, the private sector has had deeper pockets when it comes to installing the infrastructure needed for home based working. If charities are to deliver successful hybrid working, then they need to ensure their staff and volunteers have the technology and Internet speeds that will enable them to work smoothly from home as well as the office. What’s more, they must ensure their staff are trusted, treated fairly and feel supported. Involving staff (or their trade union) in the design of hybrid working systems, and staying in touch can help to anticipate and deal with any problems. As such, charities should ensure that communication within their team is as seamless as possible. Indeed, once hybrid working arrangements are up and running, regular monitoring is essential for success.